I understand the concerns expressed in Suzanne's recent post, and appreciate that some may have come to regret how Joshua Harris' book I Kissed Dating Goodbye has affected their dating philosophy.
Here's the thing, though: I think that too many people have simply read the title of Joshua's book, or heard others give caricatures of the principles explored in it, and have gone on to either reject its biblical messages altogether or embrace an anti-social perversion of it.
The author of the article that Suzanne references in her blog, for example, seems to have misunderstood what Joshua was saying, and implemented that faulty set of principles, and now has rejected it. He came to believe, for example, that the choice was between "actually speaking to a girl" and "refusing to date based on my loyalty to spiritualized groupthink." Both are bad options, and he went with the latter for a few years.
Good for him for changing his mind; bad on him for his cynical tone and mischaracterization of what Joshua had written, and for not owning up to his own relational mistakes. Instead of blaming his "insecurity" and "struggle with confidence" and "awkwardness" with dating on "some stupid, self-righteous decision I made in high school," for example, blame it on something that has a biblical remedy: fear of man.
Joshua Harris recognizes that there are many misunderstandings about his first book, and has responded to some of them on his Web site.
I still stand by the message of that book that premature, short-term romantic attachments can be a big distraction from serving God -- especially for teenagers. But in the years since I've also seen that a legalistic application of these ideas can be unhelpful, too.
One of the misapplications has been cutting off guy-girl relationships altogether, something he's not encouraging in the least:
The heart behind [this book] is not to force someone not to date or not have relationships with the opposite sex. The message behind it is really "don't pursue romance until you're really ready for commitment."
That's exactly what we say at Boundless: Dating is great when it's intentional, when you're in it to try to figure out whether someone could become your spouse.
Harris goes on:
I encourage anyone: If anything in your life becomes more important than God, and keeps you from serving Him, you should be willing to kiss it goodbye.
Joshua had just come out of a sinful relationship. He knew that the way he had been "doing dating" was wrong, principally because he hadn't put God first. May we adopt this same attitude, that if we're dating in a way that diminishes God, may we be counter-cultural enough to kiss it goodbye.
And may we stop blaming Joshua for our relational failures, own up to our misunderstandings and mistakes, and press on.
Recent Comments